Tuffy Dog Toys

Tuffy's Gary the Gator Medium

$23.88 $20.99 Sale Sold Out
2 reviews

Free Shipping

Gary in an all-new size - Soon to be your dog's best friend! This Alligator dog toy is cute enough for your kid, yet strong enough for your dog. As durable and tough as the real thing and makes a great pillow when your dog is tired! This dog toy is fun for dogs of all sizes. Gary is just waiting to chomp his way into your dog's heart! Medium Sized Gary measures 14 x 8.5 x 3. Tuffy Dog Toys are designed to be Interactive Play toys not chew toys.

Toy Type
Toy Durability
Toy Guarantee
Toy Size

More about Tuffy's Gary the Gator Medium

Tuffy Dog Toys - Sea Creatures Series Construction:

Multiple Layers Tuffy Dog Toys are the most durable toys available. This dog toy is made with one layer of soft fleece, one layer of industrial-grade luggage material, and one layer of plastic coating in the center.  All three layers are sewn together to make one "Tuff" layer.

Sewn Multiple Times Most dog toys have just one seam to hold the toy together. Tuffy Dog Toys sew webbing around the edges of the toy and then sew the edges together to make each toy Tuff.

Squeaker Safety Pockets Squeakers are sewn into pouches as an added layer of safety.

These toys are machine washable (air dry) and float.

**Tuffy Dog Toys are designed as play toys NOT chew toys. No part of any dog toy should be ingested. Injury may result. Always be present when your dog is engaged/playing with ANY toy**


- Manufacture: Tuffy Dog Toys

- MPN: T-M-OC-Alligator

- UPC: 180181910036

- Size:14 x 8.5 x 3

- Squeakers: 2

- Country of Origin:

  • China

Customer Reviews

Based on 2 reviews
Smak J.
Fairly Durable

My dog will destroy anything (including a "ballistic" chew proof bed) if given enough time. This toy has held up well and I think will last a long time as long as he is supervised while playing.

My dog's favorite plush, gary's been replaced five or so times ...

My dog's favorite plush, gary's been replaced five or so times over the past six years and repeatedly sewn back together in between the replacements. If you saw the way my pit mix plays with him, though, you'd still be impressed. I understand the low reviews, as rough as he is, my boy isn't actually trying to tear it apart. Quite the opposite, in fact, he will now baby the weakening areas so as to not have it taken away. Well, until he actually sees stuffing, then all bets are off.

I also think it's worth pointing out that a year or two ago there were some really bad batches of gary, here. They showed up already falling apart at the seams and with old, severely weakened, material. That accounts for half of my replacements and the majority of the bad reviews. The last two I've bought have been excellent quality again so here's hoping that continues to be the case.


Fast - Free 2-5 Day Shipping Contiguous US. No Memberships, No Minimum, No Exceptions.


Need Help finding the right toy? Bark with us. Just a Call, Chat or e-mail away. 1-877-341-0633 or bark@dogtuff.com

Tough Ratings

Every Toy at Dogtuff features a durability rating. The Higher the Number, the Tougher the Toy!

Featured Brands