Before You Pass the Turkey, See Which Thanksgiving Dishes Are Dangerou

Thanksgiving brings family, food, and full bellies, but for our dogs, it can also bring hidden dangers on the dinner table. While your pup may give you those irresistible “please share” eyes, many classic holiday dishes contain ingredients that are toxic or unsafe for dogs.

At DogTuff, we’re all about safe, durable fun — and that extends beyond toys. So we analyzed 50 of the most popular Thanksgiving recipes to see how many are actually dog-safe. The results might surprise you!

📊 The DogTuff Thanksgiving Safety Breakdown

Out of 50 traditional Thanksgiving recipes:

🔴 26 are potentially dangerous for dogs
🟡 7 are moderately unsafe (can cause mild illness or stomach upset)
🟢 17 are considered dog-safe when served plain and unseasoned

That means over half of the typical Thanksgiving menu includes ingredients that could harm your pup.

🚫 The Hidden Hazards on the Thanksgiving Table

Many dishes share the same culprits, ingredients that may seem harmless to humans but are dangerous for dogs.

Common Offenders:

Onions, Garlic & Leeks – Found in stuffings, gravies, and side dishes. These can damage red blood cells and cause anemia.
Nutmeg – Popular in pies and casseroles, nutmeg can cause tremors and seizures in dogs.
Grapes & Raisins – Even tiny amounts can lead to kidney failure.
Alcohol & Caffeine – Found in drinks, desserts, and sauces — both can be toxic.
Rich Fats, Bones & Skin – Can trigger pancreatitis or choking.
Nuts (especially pecans, almonds, macadamia) – Cause vomiting, lethargy, or worse.

🦴 Safer Ways to Include Your Pup in the Feast

You don’t have to leave your dog out of the celebration — just serve them a dog-safe version!

Try these simple swaps:

Instead of Stuffing: Offer a spoon of plain sweet potatoes or green beans.
Instead of Pie: Give a frozen peanut butter treat in a Toppl Treat Toy

Perfect 👍 — I’ll expand this into a full, grouped table for all 50 Thanksgiving recipes, now including the dog-safety severity column for every dish.

Here’s the complete breakdown:

🦃 Main Dishes

Dish	Key Ingredients	Dog-Dangerous?	Hazard Ingredient(s)	Severity
Herb-Roasted Turkey	Turkey, olive oil, butter, rosemary, thyme, garlic, salt, pepper	Yes	Garlic	🔴 High
Brined Turkey	Turkey, water, salt, brown sugar, bay leaves, peppercorns, herbs	Yes	Excess salt (brine)	🟡 Moderate
Spatchcocked Turkey	Turkey, olive oil, lemon zest, garlic, herbs, salt, pepper	Yes	Garlic	🔴 High
Turkey Breast Roast	Turkey breast, olive oil, butter, sage, thyme, garlic, pepper	Yes	Garlic	🔴 High
Cornish Hens with Herbs	Cornish hens, rosemary, thyme, garlic, olive oil, lemon	Yes	Garlic	🔴 High
Roast Beef Tenderloin	Beef tenderloin, salt, pepper, garlic, olive oil, thyme, butter	Yes	Garlic	🔴 High
Vegetarian Stuffed Squash	Acorn squash, quinoa, cranberries, spinach, pecans, maple syrup	Yes	Pecans	🟡 Moderate

🍞 Stuffings & Dressings

Dish	Key Ingredients	Dog-Dangerous?	Hazard Ingredient(s)	Severity
Classic Bread Stuffing	Bread cubes, onion, celery, sage, thyme, butter, broth	Yes	Onion	🔴 High
Cornbread Stuffing	Cornbread, sausage, onion, celery, sage, butter, broth	Yes	Onion	🔴 High
Sausage & Herb Stuffing	Italian sausage, bread cubes, onions, celery, sage, thyme	Yes	Onion	🔴 High
Brioche Stuffing with Apples & Leeks	Brioche, apples, leeks, butter, parsley, broth	Yes	Leeks	🔴 High

🥣 Gravy, Sauces & Condiments

Dish	Key Ingredients	Dog-Dangerous?	Hazard Ingredient(s)	Severity
Turkey Gravy	Turkey drippings, flour, butter, chicken stock, salt, pepper	No	—	🟢 Low
Cranberry Sauce	Cranberries, sugar, orange zest, orange juice, cinnamon	No	—	🟢 Low
Cranberry-Apple Relish	Cranberries, apples, sugar, lemon juice, cinnamon	No	—	🟢 Low
Mushroom Gravy	Mushrooms, butter, flour, vegetable broth, soy sauce, thyme	No*	— (wild mushrooms only)	🟡 Moderate (if wild mushrooms)

🥔 Potatoes & Starches

Dish	Key Ingredients	Dog-Dangerous?	Hazard Ingredient(s)	Severity
Mashed Potatoes	Potatoes, butter, cream, salt, pepper	No	—	🟢 Low
Garlic Mashed Potatoes	Potatoes, roasted garlic, butter, cream, salt	Yes	Garlic	🔴 High
Sweet Potato Casserole	Sweet potatoes, brown sugar, butter, nutmeg, marshmallows	Yes	Nutmeg	🔴 High
Scalloped Potatoes	Potatoes, heavy cream, butter, garlic, Gruyère cheese	Yes	Garlic	🔴 High
Roasted Baby Potatoes	Baby potatoes, olive oil, rosemary, salt, pepper	No	—	🟢 Low
Hasselback Potatoes	Potatoes, olive oil, butter, thyme, salt, pepper	No	—	🟢 Low

🥦 Vegetable Sides

Dish	Key Ingredients	Dog-Dangerous?	Hazard Ingredient(s)	Severity
Green Bean Casserole	Green beans, cream of mushroom soup, fried onions	Yes	Onions	🔴 High
Roasted Brussels Sprouts with Bacon	Brussels sprouts, bacon, olive oil, salt, pepper	No	—	🟢 Low
Butternut Squash Soup	Butternut squash, onions, garlic, broth, cream	Yes	Onion & Garlic	🔴 High
Roasted Root Vegetables	Carrots, parsnips, sweet potatoes, olive oil, thyme	No	—	🟢 Low
Creamed Kale	Kale, cream, butter, nutmeg	Yes	Nutmeg	🔴 High
Brussels Sprouts Salad with Pomegranate	Brussels sprouts, pomegranate, pecans, vinaigrette	Yes	Pecans	🟡 Moderate
Corn Pudding	Corn, milk, eggs, sugar, flour, butter	No	—	🟢 Low
Dinner Rolls	Flour, yeast, butter, sugar, milk, salt	No	— (baked dough safe)	🟢 Low

🥗 Salads & Fresh Sides

Dish	Key Ingredients	Dog-Dangerous?	Hazard Ingredient(s)	Severity
Fall Harvest Salad	Mixed greens, roasted squash, cranberries, pecans, vinaigrette	Yes	Pecans	🟡 Moderate
Persimmon Caprese Salad	Persimmons, mozzarella, basil, olive oil, balsamic glaze	No	—	🟢 Low
Brussels Sprout Slaw	Brussels sprouts, apples, almonds, vinaigrette	Yes†	Almonds	🟡 Moderate
Kale Salad with Cranberries	Kale, dried cranberries, sunflower seeds, lemon dressing	No	—	🟢 Low

🧀 Appetizers & Starters

Dish	Key Ingredients	Dog-Dangerous?	Hazard Ingredient(s)	Severity
Cheese Board	Cheeses, crackers, grapes, figs, nuts	Yes	Grapes	🔴 High
Baked Brie with Cranberry Compote	Brie, cranberry sauce, puff pastry, honey	No	—	🟢 Low
Spinach-Artichoke Dip	Spinach, artichokes, cream cheese, parmesan	No*	— (watch for garlic/onion)	🟡 Moderate (if seasoned)
Stuffed Mushrooms	Mushrooms, breadcrumbs, garlic, parmesan, herbs	Yes	Garlic	🔴 High
Pumpkin Soup Shooter	Pumpkin purée, cream, nutmeg, cinnamon	Yes	Nutmeg	🔴 High
Fig & Prosciutto Crostini	Baguette, figs, prosciutto, goat cheese, honey	No	—	🟢 Low

🥧 Desserts

Dish	Key Ingredients	Dog-Dangerous?	Hazard Ingredient(s)	Severity
Pumpkin Pie	Pumpkin purée, eggs, sugar, nutmeg, crust	Yes	Nutmeg	🔴 High
Sweet Potato Pie	Sweet potatoes, brown sugar, eggs, butter, nutmeg	Yes	Nutmeg	🔴 High
Pecan Pie	Pecans, corn syrup, brown sugar, eggs, vanilla	Yes	Pecans	🟡 Moderate
Apple Crisp	Apples, oats, brown sugar, butter, cinnamon	No	—	🟢 Low
Pumpkin Cheesecake	Pumpkin purée, cream cheese, sugar, nutmeg	Yes	Nutmeg	🔴 High
Cranberry Bread Pudding	Brioche, cranberries, eggs, cream, sugar	No	—	🟢 Low
Mini Pumpkin Muffins	Pumpkin purée, flour, sugar, cinnamon, nutmeg	Yes	Nutmeg	🔴 High

✅ Summary Insight:

Most Dangerous (🔴 High): Garlic, onions, leeks, nutmeg, grapes, alcohol, caffeine
Moderate (🟡): Pecans, almonds, excess salt, wild mushrooms, rich dairy sauces
Safe (🟢): Plain vegetables, potatoes, turkey/meat (unseasoned, no bones, no gravy)

Before You Pass the Turkey, See Which Thanksgiving Dishes Are Dangerous for Dogs

Chew Smart. Chew Safe

Family-Owned Small Biz

Tested by Tough Chewers

Fast Shipping from Florida

Cart

Select options